He has died three years ago.这句话对不对?如果错的话,为什么终止性动词可以用于现在完成时?

Question

不是He has died for years ago.

Answer 1

错的。终止性动词可以用于现在完成时，但句中不能有“for +一段时间”或“一段时间+ago”的时间状语

He has died或He died three years ago或He has been dead for three years均为正确表达。

Answer 2

不对。完成时态表示的是从过去一直延续到现在的动作，还有可能延续到将来；或者是过去发生的动作对现在造成的影响。既然强调的是对现在的一种影响，就没有必要用陈述性的语言对过去的事情进行具体的描述。所以一定要用完成时态的话应该改成He has been died for 3 years ago.表示一段时间而不是具体的时间点。否则要说明具体时间点只能用过去时态，就是把has去掉啊。

Answer 3

three years ago是一个时间点，只能用一般过去式，而he has been dead for three years是可以的，应为这里死（been dead）已经成了一种可持续的状态了本回答被提问者采纳

Answer 4

不对

应该是He has been dead for three years/ He died three years ago

Answer 5

错,"死"不能延续